57 Chestnut Street, Sag Harbor, NY 11963

A charming Sag Harbor cottage just moments from the waterfront, offering a rare opportunity to renovate, expand, or build your dream Hamptons’ retreat.

img 6367
new9
new10
new8
hf 20260710 185533 c033ad24 d995 4c6b 818d 1186ad12a147
hf 20260711 145920 d3e469fb 06be 4021 871c d63a7ed15384
img 6363
hf 20260710 183916 e52e76b0 7b0f 4ef6 9848 5dda3bd99167
unnamed (7)
new3
new6
new11
hf 20260710 224703 5dd65835 007b 4855 9570 ddf740610601
img 6368
unnamed
unnamed (33)
unnamed (31)
unnamed (30)
unnamed (29)
unnamed (15)
unnamed (10)
unnamed (9)
unnamed (8)
unnamed (4)
hf 20260710 185346 6b02fb19 fa9b 4ae2 8c49 a67200bddfcc
unnamed (35)
a93308b1 d347 45c4 826d 86f14dbb1ed7 preview
new5
new4
new2
new1
ew3
new

Fully Permitted and Entitled Existing Surverys

(Plus, breathtaking water views from the second story.)

Existing surveys and plans are available, making it easy to envision a renovation or expansion while enjoying one of Sag Harbor’s most desirable locations.

screenshot
screenshot
fixed

Steps from Circle Beach and Sag Harbor Bay

Nestled just a short stroll from the shoreline.

golden sunrise on the north shore of long island
screenshot 2026 07 01 at 11.40.42 am
screenshot 2026 07 09 at 2.20.58 am
screenshot 2026 07 09 at 2.22.14 am

Exclusive: $1,459,000

Current Cottage Conditons:

2 Bedrooms
1 Bathroom
942 SF Living Area
7,405 SF Lot
Attic, Basement, Crawl Space
New HVAC System
Minutes to Circle Beach
Private Driveway
Spray Foam Insulation
Irrigation System
Water Views From Second Story

Discover More

Book a private tour or get extra information:

+1 (917) 846 5057
francesca@francescaevents.com